The Top 10 Challenges Faced by Design Engineers in Manufacturing and How to Overcome Them

Design engineers are vital to the product development lifecycle, transforming concepts into precise technical drawings and 3D models using Computer-Aided Design (CAD) software. They must balance creative vision with practical constraints, working closely with teams like manufacturing and procurement. Navigating industrial design and manufacturing presents numerous challenges. Here are ten key difficulties faced by design engineers, along with how solutions like CADDi can help overcome them.

1. High CAD Software Costs

Industrial design professionals often encounter high license and hardware costs associated with CAD software. This represents a significant operational pain point, leading to reduced ROI and budget strain for companies.

How CADDi Helps: While CADDi Drawer is a software solution with associated costs, its ability to dramatically increase efficiency and unlock cost savings in other areas, such as procurement and value analysis, can help offset overall technology spending. By reducing manual work and enabling better data utilization, it contributes to cost reduction and improved profitability across the value chain.

2. CAD File Compatibility Issues

A significant challenge is the loss of contextual data when transferring CAD files between different software systems. This lack of seamless compatibility leads to extensive rework and project delays.

How CADDi Helps: CADDi Drawer focuses on extracting and utilizing data from drawing files, regardless of the specific CAD software used to create them. It can process data from various sources and link it together, mitigating some issues related to incompatible file formats by providing a centralized, searchable repository of drawing information and associated data.

3. CAD Software Usability and Steep Learning Curve

CAD systems can have a steep learning curve and non-intuitive interfaces. This makes software usability a significant pain point, contributing to slow adoption and a skills gap within teams.

How CADDi Helps: CADDi Drawer is designed for ease of use, with features like intelligent search and a viewer that allows multiple drawings to be viewed at once. Its user-friendly interface encourages rapid adoption among employees. Junior employees at companies were able to make impactful decisions and become adept users quickly. CADDi made information much more accessible, even for less experienced individuals who could search by keywords or similar drawings instead of needing to memorize ID numbers.

4. Version Control Problems and Lost Work

Accidental overwrites and lost work due to inadequate version control systems are common frustrations. This compromises data integrity and can lead to project setbacks.

How CADDi Helps: CADDi maintains a searchable archive of drawings and linking related data, including design revisions. By providing a centralized, accessible record of historical drawings and associated information, it can help manage the complexity of revisions and ensure teams are referencing the correct documentation. The ability to easily identify differences between revisions is a key feature.

5. Fragmented Data Storage and Data Silos

Data organization is a major challenge faced by designers, characterized by fragmented storage and the existence of data silos across different departments and systems. This makes it difficult to find necessary information and contributes to errors.

How CADDi Helps: CADDi Drawer acts as a data lake, connecting information across various tools and silos, including PLM, PDM, ERP, and CAD systems. It centralizes the management of documents and data, breaking down siloed structures by using drawings as a shared medium to link supplier data, purchasing data, quality data, and various document groups. This integrated approach provides a holistic view of each drawing in the context of the broader business and supply chain.

6. Inefficient Search for Design Data

Finding relevant historical design data is often inefficient due to fragmented storage and poor data organization. Traditional search methods relying on part IDs or names are limiting. This leads design engineers to have to “reinvent the wheel” every time a new drawing is needed, rather than working from a similar previous design or wholly reusing it.

How CADDi Helps: CADDi revolutionizes data search in manufacturing. It automatically indexes drawings and makes them searchable using keywords found within the drawing itself, such as material, size, designer, part name, and notes. Crucially, its patented similarity search technology allows users to find similar drawings based on shape, even from handwritten sketches or old records, eliminating the need to know specific IDs. This significantly reduces the time spent searching.

7. Collaboration Issues and Fragmented Information

Siloed teams and fragmented information undermine cross-functional collaboration. This leads to misaligned efforts and project delays. Effective data management is critical for cross-functional collaboration, particularly between engineering, procurement, production, and quality assurance.

How CADDi Helps: By centralizing drawing data and linking it with information from other departments (procurement, sales, quality, etc.), CADDi facilitates better collaboration across teams and sites. Providing shared, easily accessible data helps bridge gaps between departments, such as the one between creators and users of drawings. This improved data access allows teams like procurement to collaborate with engineering earlier and more effectively.

8. The Gap Between Design and Manufacturing/Cost Realities

There is a persistent disconnect between design (aesthetics) and the practical realities of engineering, manufacturing, and cost-effectiveness. Designs may be difficult or costly to produce, leading to extensive rework and compromising market viability. Engineering input regarding manufacturability is crucial but often challenging to integrate early on.

How CADDi Helps: CADDi helps bridge this gap by linking design data with manufacturing, quality, and cost information. By providing a holistic view of designs alongside their historical manufacturing outcomes and costs, design engineers can gain insights into the manufacturability and cost implications of their choices. The ability to find similar parts with different pricing helps identify opportunities for cost reduction and value engineering from the design stage. Analyzing drawing data, as enabled by CADDi, can reveal material usage rates or potential manufacturing difficulties, allowing proactive adjustments.

9. Increased Rework and Project Delays

Inefficiencies stemming from issues like file interoperability, version control problems, fragmented data, collaboration breakdowns, and the design-manufacturing gap often result in extensive rework and project delays.

How CADDi Helps: By addressing the root causes of rework and delays, such as inefficient data access, poor collaboration, and a lack of insight into manufacturability, CADDi Drawer helps streamline workflows. Faster searching for relevant historical designs and associated data reduces the time spent on initial design stages and prevents common issues like designing parts inconsistently from previous cost-effective options. Improved collaboration and data transparency reduce misunderstandings and errors that lead to rework. Overall, the tool saves significant time on non-productive tasks, freeing up design engineers for higher-value work.

10. Difficulty Balancing Aesthetics with Manufacturability and Cost

Design engineers often face the challenge of balancing aesthetic requirements with the need for manufacturability and cost-effectiveness. The perception exists that some designers prioritize form over the practicalities of production, leading to designs that are difficult or costly to produce.

How CADDi Helps: CADDi directly supports the crucial consideration of costs, manufacturing processes, and vendor quotes from the beginning of a project. By linking design data with procurement information, cost breakdowns, and manufacturing feedback, it provides designers with the data needed to make informed decisions that balance aesthetics with practical constraints. The ability to find similar designs and analyze their cost implications helps engineers understand the relationship between design features and price, guiding them towards more cost-effective design choices without sacrificing necessary functionality. This enables fact-based decision making to reduce costs and improve quality.

In conclusion, design engineers face a multitude of challenges related to data management, collaboration, and the practicalities of manufacturing. By providing a centralized, searchable, and interconnected platform for drawing data and related business information, CADDi helps address these pain points, enabling design engineers to work more efficiently, collaboratively, and strategically to create designs that are both innovative and manufacturable.

Ready to see how CADDi can help address your key design challenges? Explore our interactive product tour or book a personalized demo.

‍